“The Complete TurtleTrader” is an inspiring story that proves trading success can be taught. By emphasizing a systematic approach and removing emotions from trading decisions, Richard Dennis showed that anyone can become a successful trader with the right training and discipline. The lessons from this book are timeless and apply to anyone looking to gain an edge in the financial markets. It is a must-read for aspiring traders, as it demonstrates the power of following a proven system over personal instincts or emotions.
The CompleteTurtleTrader by Michael W. Covel Summary
Chapter 1: Nurture versus Nature
In this chapter, Richard Dennis, a successful Chicago trader, initiated a groundbreaking experiment that would challenge the widely held belief that successful trading required innate talent. The nature versus nurture debate between Dennis and his partner, William Eckhardt, set the foundation for this real-life experiment. Dennis believed that anyone, regardless of background or prior experience, could be taught how to trade successfully, as long as they were given a clear set of rules and training. On the other hand, Eckhardt believed that successful trading required an inherent, almost instinctive skill set.
Dennis’s goal was to prove that trading was teachable through systematic and empirical methods. He placed advertisements in financial publications to recruit people with no previous trading experience. His philosophy emphasized that trading was not about luck or intuition but about following rules, understanding probabilities, and managing risk. This chapter sets the stage for the Turtle experiment, where Dennis would ultimately prove that nurture could triumph over nature in the trading world.
Chapter 2: The Prince of the Pit
This chapter delves into Richard Dennis’s early career as he rose from the chaotic trading pits of Chicago to become a legend in the financial world. Starting as a runner on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, Dennis quickly learned the ropes of floor trading. Despite his lack of formal training in finance, his height, quick reflexes, and ability to see over the crowds gave him a physical advantage in the crowded and aggressive trading pits. He used this to his benefit, becoming known for his ability to spot profitable trades and execute them swiftly.
Dennis’s strategy was based on understanding probabilities, not emotions, a key trait that would later define his trading philosophy. His early success allowed him to leave the pits and form C&D Commodities, where he began trading on a much larger scale. By doing this, Dennis expanded beyond the floor, proving that his disciplined approach to trading could thrive in any market. The chapter highlights his adaptability, intellectual rigor, and rapid rise in the trading world.
Chapter 3: The Turtles
In this chapter, the focus shifts to the selection and recruitment process for the famous Turtle experiment. Richard Dennis and his partner, William Eckhardt, placed ads in financial publications like The Wall Street Journal, searching for individuals willing to be trained in Dennis’s proprietary trading methods. What made this experiment unique was that Dennis intentionally sought candidates with little to no prior trading experience, defying the industry norm that only seasoned professionals could succeed in trading.
The selected candidates, who would later be known as the “Turtles,” came from a wide variety of backgrounds, including accounting, music, and even board game design. Dennis believed that following strict rules and disciplined approaches to trading were more important than any innate talent or financial background. This diverse group of students was about to embark on a journey that would prove that trading could indeed be taught. This chapter lays the groundwork for the Turtle experiment by demonstrating how ordinary people were given the chance to make extraordinary profits under Dennis’s mentorship.
Chapter 4: The Philosophy
This chapter dives into the core philosophy behind Richard Dennis’s approach to trading, which he passed on to the Turtles. Dennis believed that trading success was not based on intuition or gut feelings but on a systematic, rule-based approach that could be learned by anyone. He emphasized the importance of trend-following, a strategy where traders capitalize on the momentum of market trends rather than trying to predict reversals.
Dennis’s philosophy was rooted in empirical data and the scientific method, where observation, experience, and statistical analysis drove trading decisions. The Turtles were taught to disregard market noise and emotion, focusing instead on price movements and objective signals. One key element of this philosophy was discipline—traders had to follow the system’s rules strictly, even when it felt uncomfortable or counterintuitive. This chapter highlights how Dennis viewed trading as a psychological challenge as much as a financial one, with the ability to maintain discipline under pressure being a critical component of long-term success.
Chapter 5: The Rules
Chapter 5 outlines the detailed set of rules that Richard Dennis and William Eckhardt created to guide the Turtles in their trading activities. These rules were the backbone of Dennis’s systematic approach, designed to remove emotional bias from trading decisions and ensure consistency. One of the key principles was risk management. The Turtles were trained to use volatility-based position sizing, which means the amount they traded depended on the market’s volatility. Higher volatility meant smaller positions to minimize risk, while lower volatility allowed for larger positions.
Another critical rule was cutting losses quickly. The Turtles were instructed to set predefined stop-loss levels and exit trades when the market moved against them. At the same time, they were taught to let profits run by staying in winning trades as long as the trend continued. This approach ensured that large losses were avoided, and winning trades could grow substantially.
Dennis also introduced technical indicators, such as moving averages, to signal entry and exit points, reinforcing the importance of objective, data-driven decisions. This chapter highlights how these rules were crucial in making the Turtle experiment a success, providing a systematic framework that could be followed regardless of market conditions.
Chapter 6: In the Womb
This chapter focuses on the intense two-week training period that the Turtles underwent, which laid the foundation for their trading careers. During this time, Richard Dennis and William Eckhardt drilled their recruits in the principles of their trend-following system, emphasizing the importance of discipline and rule-following. The Turtles learned how to analyze markets, spot trends, and use technical indicators like moving averages to guide their trading decisions.
One of the major challenges the Turtles faced was overcoming the natural human instinct to act on emotion, especially when markets became volatile. Dennis and Eckhardt stressed that successful trading required ignoring these emotions and sticking strictly to the system, even when it seemed counterintuitive. This chapter also illustrates how the Turtles struggled with the psychological pressure of trading real money, with some doubting their abilities and others thriving under the structured environment.
The phrase “In the Womb” reflects the idea that the Turtles were being nurtured and developed during this formative period, where they transitioned from novices to professional traders under the careful guidance of Dennis. The chapter underscores how crucial this initial training was in shaping the future success of the Turtles, teaching them that mastering the system was more important than relying on personal judgment or intuition.
Chapter 7: Who Got What to Trade
In this chapter, Richard Dennis assigned each Turtle an initial amount of capital to trade, ranging from $500,000 to $2 million, depending on their performance and confidence level. The allocation of funds was a critical moment in the Turtle experiment, as it put Dennis’s system to the test in real-world conditions with significant amounts of money. The Turtles’ trades were monitored closely, and Dennis evaluated their adherence to the system’s rules rather than their immediate profitability.
This chapter highlights the differences in how the Turtles responded to the psychological pressure of trading large sums. Some thrived, fully embracing the rules of trend-following and executing trades with confidence. Others struggled, unable to shake the emotional challenges that came with trading. Dennis’s system dictated that traders would experience many small losses but achieve large gains when trends persisted, making psychological resilience essential.
The chapter also explores how the Turtles were encouraged to manage risk through position sizing, ensuring they didn’t overexpose themselves to any single market. The varied results among the Turtles emphasized the importance of mental toughness and the ability to trust the system, even when faced with short-term losses. Ultimately, this chapter shows that, while the rules were uniform, the individual Turtles’ success depended heavily on their ability to stay disciplined and manage the emotional highs and lows of trading.
Chapter 8: Game Over
This chapter marks the end of the official Turtle experiment, as Richard Dennis decided to shut down the program after several years of running it. By this point, the Turtles had proven the success of the trend-following system Dennis had taught them, with many generating substantial profits. However, despite the success of the program, Dennis had personal reasons for concluding the experiment, including changes in market conditions and his own desire to step back from managing the group.
The chapter also explores how the Turtles reacted to the end of the program. Some were disappointed, as they had relied on Dennis’s guidance and financial backing to grow as traders. Others viewed it as an opportunity to branch out and apply the skills they had learned independently. Despite the program’s closure, the lessons and trading rules the Turtles had learned remained valuable, and many went on to build successful careers on their own.
“Game Over” signifies the closing of a chapter, but it also highlights the lasting impact of the Turtle experiment. The Turtles had learned to follow a proven system and trust in the rules, skills they would carry forward in their individual trading ventures. This chapter underscores that the experiment was not just a short-term success but a transformative experience that shaped the Turtles’ future in trading.
Chapter 9: Out on Their Own
This chapter explores the Turtles’ journeys after the official end of the Turtle experiment. With the closure of the program, many Turtles ventured out to establish their own trading careers, using the skills and strategies they had learned from Richard Dennis. This transition marked a significant turning point in their lives, as they moved from being guided and funded by Dennis to trading independently.
Some Turtles thrived in their new roles, building highly successful careers in trading and even managing hedge funds. Their adherence to the systematic, trend-following approach Dennis had taught them became a cornerstone of their success. The chapter highlights notable Turtles like Jerry Parker, who went on to manage Chesapeake Capital, and others who leveraged the knowledge gained to make millions.
However, not all Turtles found the same level of success. Some struggled to replicate the performance they had achieved under Dennis’s mentorship, facing challenges in handling the psychological pressures of independent trading or navigating new market conditions. This chapter reveals that while the system worked, individual resilience and discipline played a critical role in long-term success.
The chapter emphasizes the lasting influence of the Turtle experiment on the financial world, as many Turtles became well-respected traders in their own right, proving that Dennis’s experiment had a significant and enduring impact.
Chapter 10: Dennis Comes Back to the Game
In this chapter, Richard Dennis makes a return to trading after taking a break following the closure of the Turtle experiment. Despite his previous successes, his comeback was marked by mixed results, as both the markets and Dennis himself had changed. The chapter delves into the challenges Dennis faced upon his return, including the evolution of financial markets and the increasing prominence of new trading technologies and strategies that did not exist during his earlier career.
Dennis remained a firm believer in trend-following and systematic trading, but his performance post-comeback did not reach the heights of his earlier achievements. The chapter also touches on the emotional and psychological toll of trading, especially after experiencing previous success, and how this impacted Dennis’s return. Ultimately, this chapter highlights how even a trading legend like Dennis could face difficulties in adapting to a rapidly changing market environment, demonstrating the ongoing evolution and challenges of the financial world.
Chapter 11: Seizing Opportunity
Chapter 11 focuses on the mindset and strategies required to seize opportunities in the market. Dennis taught the Turtles that success in trading was often about recognizing and acting on trends quickly and decisively. The Turtles were trained to follow the rules of the system strictly, but this chapter emphasizes that spotting opportunities within those rules was key to maximizing profits.
The chapter underscores the importance of having the courage to take risks when opportunities arise, as well as the discipline to act without hesitation. It highlights instances where Turtles who followed the system diligently were able to capitalize on significant market trends, turning seemingly small opportunities into large gains. Conversely, those who hesitated or deviated from the system missed out on potential profits. The message in this chapter is clear: trading success is not just about having a strategy but about being prepared and confident enough to seize opportunities when they present themselves.
Chapter 12: Failure Is a Choice
In this chapter, the narrative explores the idea that failure in trading is often a result of personal choices rather than market conditions. Richard Dennis’s system was proven to work, and the Turtles who stuck to the rules found success. However, the chapter also discusses how some traders, even with a proven system, still failed. The common factor in these failures was a lack of discipline—traders who allowed emotions, fear, or greed to override the system’s rules experienced losses.
Dennis had always taught the Turtles that sticking to the plan, even during tough times, was essential. However, those who veered away from the rules, hoping for quick gains or trying to avoid small losses, often saw their trading capital erode. The chapter reinforces the idea that trading success is about long-term consistency and discipline. In essence, the chapter posits that failure is a choice—one that comes from not adhering to a proven system or allowing human biases to interfere with disciplined trading.
Chapter 13: Second-Generation Turtles
This chapter explores the ripple effect of the Turtle experiment beyond its original participants. Some of the original Turtles, having found success in the markets, went on to teach and mentor others, creating a “second generation” of traders who adopted Richard Dennis’s trend-following system. The second-generation Turtles applied the same rules and principles that Dennis had taught, demonstrating that the system was replicable and continued to be effective even years after the original experiment.
The chapter also highlights the influence of the Turtle system on broader financial circles. Many of the Turtles became thought leaders and experts in the trading world, sharing their insights through books, lectures, and trading firms. This spread of knowledge extended the legacy of the Turtle experiment, cementing Dennis’s belief that trading could be taught and learned by anyone with discipline. The success of the second-generation Turtles served as further proof of the lasting impact of the original experiment.
Chapter 14: Model Greatness
In the final chapter, the book reflects on the lasting significance of Richard Dennis’s Turtle experiment. The experiment not only created millionaire traders but also established a model of systematic, rules-based trading that continues to influence the financial world. Dennis’s methods have been adopted by many hedge funds and professional traders, and the trend-following philosophy remains relevant in today’s markets.
The chapter emphasizes that the greatness of the Turtle experiment lies in its ability to democratize trading. Dennis proved that ordinary individuals, with no prior experience, could become successful traders if they adhered to a proven system. This chapter also underscores the idea that greatness in trading is not about intuition or special talent, but about discipline, resilience, and a willingness to follow a set of rules.
The legacy of the Turtle experiment is one of empowerment—demonstrating that with the right mindset and tools, anyone can achieve financial success in the markets. This final chapter serves as a conclusion to the story of the Turtles, encapsulating the lessons learned and the broader implications of their journey.
Why You Should Buy and Read The Complete TurtleTrader
The Complete TurtleTrader by Michael Covel is an inspiring and educational must-read for anyone looking to understand how ordinary people can achieve extraordinary financial success through disciplined trading. It tells the captivating true story of how legendary trader Richard Dennis turned a group of inexperienced individuals—known as the “Turtles”—into millionaire traders using a systematic, rules-based approach.
This book is perfect for anyone interested in the financial markets, trading, or personal development. It demystifies complex financial concepts and proves that trading success is not about luck or intuition but about discipline, risk management, and following a proven system. Covel not only explains Dennis’s powerful trend-following strategy but also delivers actionable insights that anyone can apply, regardless of their background.
With gripping personal stories of the Turtles’ challenges and triumphs, this book is both highly informative and entertaining. If you want to learn from one of the most successful trading experiments in history and discover how discipline and strategy can transform your approach to the markets, The Complete TurtleTrader is a must-read.
This post is part of Making Money in the Stock Market, where you can read about the overview of strategies in investment and short term trading.